Discussion

How do you measure your contribution to the climate crisis?

Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS
Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS • 11 February 2022

Hi everyone!

In a recent article I read, the author considers the "carbon footprint" concept - i.e. the tool for calculating how much each one of us is contributing to the climate crisis - ubiquitous. The reason, she says, is that our footprints "do not paint an accurate picture of our true individual impact" on the climate. Instead, she proposes the alternative concept of the "climate shadow" through which own can visualise the sum of one's life choices. 

I am not advocating in favor of one term or the other. On the contrary, I think constant introduction of new terms in the already complex sphere of the climate emergency may inhibit climate action. However, I truly believe that when assessing our true individual contribution to the climate crisis we need to visualize the sum of our consumption, choices, and attention.

 

Along with taking small, concrete, and quantifiable action(s) (e.g. recycling, reduce our air conditioning use or the gas mileage of our car) we also need to engage in more impactful and meaningful work (e.g. lobbying local politicians and voting smart, speaking up at work about wasteful practices, think of how we invest our money) and contemplate whether we behave with urgency, apathy, or denial. The latter, in my opinion, is especially important when we interact, engage, or teach children.

 

In short, each of us needs to undergo a kind of spiritual reckoning, and ultimately unleash the power of collective action.

With the present post I would like to start a discussion on your own thoughts on the matter and on any methods and tools you might know of - or have even used - to assess your own impact/contribution to the climate crisis. Has anyone tried to measure the impact of his classroom, school, or university? With what type of measurements?  Are there any related projects you have come across or implemented? What are the difficulties you encounter and how did you manage to overcome them? Any lessons learned you would like to share with the Community? 

Best regards to all,

Vassilis

Comments (12)

Nicole BRUTTOMESSO
Nicole BRUTTOMESSO

Good points, Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS ! I think that we should all take our time to reflect about the impact of our consumptions and choices and commit to both individual and impactful collective practices and actions if we want to face this climate crisis.

Do you have any idea or experience to share with the community? Vitor Oliveira Carmen Gabriela BOSTAN Jeroen Onck Selvaggia Santin David Crookall Ada Lungu Philip Lambrechts Githinji Kamotho ASPASIA MYLONA Roberta MOSCA Emmanuelle Mouls Orla Farrell Alan Hesse Raffael Krepel Lavinia ANDREI Alice Dalle Stavroula Skiada Iva NaranÄ‘a Roberta Bellini ANESTIS PA Thijs Struijk  

Vitor Oliveira
Vitor Oliveira

Hi there!

As a Biology/Geology teacher I always try to lead my students into realizing that our present lives’ pattern is absolutely unsustainable; we take much more from nature than it is prepared to let go.

Of course, in class we reflect on how individuals may contribute to collective action and change, starting at family level. Most students are, in fact, a major changing force within their families, and I do listen to a lot of stories of parents’ resistance to change old habits and how students are many times able to break inertia. Of course, sometimes they’re not.

It is visible, for instance, that the number of vegetarians or low animal protein intake students is steadily on the rise in Portugal and we all certainly know that the intensive meat and fish production is one of the major culprits when we analyze our current environmental problems.

But there’s a lot more that we all need to do than to act individually, particularly at the regional/national/EU level, namely implementing strong and bold new environmental policies that will place the EU at its historical and political place, the one of leader of freedom, peace, rule of justice and environmental protection. All these aspects are part of the sustainable development fabric, if they fail all actions will be merely palliative and all major decisions and outcomes will be postponed.

Time is of essence, and I do believe that time, in this issue, is not on our side. We are lucky enough (we all know that it’s not luck, it’s the hard work of previous generations that we must honor and sustain) to live in the most advanced and civilized world’s area and it is our duty to carry this flame, the flame of humanity’s reconciliation with nature.

We must change our role from nature plunders to nature keepers, and we must do it as quickly as necessary, there is simply no alternative.

Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS
Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS

Very inspiring words - and work - Vitor! Thank you for this. Indeed, we have such a short time to change behaviors that have been deeply instilled into the older generations. I agree that young people are a changing force in society (as they are the future global citizens who will need to face the future challenges) and their families. The latter are a critical target group to influence - due to the lack of time. I was wondering whether you have any related statics on this influence, any common trends or characteristics of the parents/families that do show a change in behavior or of the children who do succeed in influencing their families. Many thanks!

Vitor Oliveira
Vitor Oliveira

Hi Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS.

My personal experience tells me that there is a clear link between the parents' academic level, their participations on society's decision making, and their willingness to cooperate with their children's "new" proposals. Although this is not an absolute truth, there is certainly a link between these factors (higher schooling level, higher social participation = higher cooperation on change).

I do believe, however, that it is too late to wait for the cooperation of the entire society (or for the vast majority of people) and expect it will be entirely effective; resolute action at the decision level (national/EU) is also crucial.

On other words, some more unpopular measures mus be enforced. Honestly, most people are willing to protect the planet on the condition that it doesn't affect their current living standard. And I'm afraid those are opposite goals, one simply cannot eat the cake and keep it!

Democracies face a thougher task here, some people (a surprising large percentage of people) don't seem able to face the facts and decide rationally, just remember some reactions to the current pandemic situation...

We must walk a fine line between education/cooperation and rule of law, hope for the best and prepare for the worst. Not a very bright perspective, I know...

Tremeur DENIGOT
Tremeur DENIGOT

This Consumer Footprint Calculator has been developed by our colleagues scientists of the Joint Research Centre. It is quite powerful. Very complete, even a bit too much maybe, as it covers 16 environmental impact indicators, but it gives a good idea of the complexity of calculating one's consumption pattern and how this pattern has an impact on environment. To use it properly with students, they would need to investigate their own consumption pattern and gather the data, and they will then have an idea of their impact. Nice tool I think, opening to many possible didactic uses. Freely accessible knowledge of course. Enjoy. https://knowsdgs.jrc.ec.europa.eu/cfc

Vitor Oliveira
Vitor Oliveira

Great tool, but I do believe it is too complex for lower secondary students. A trimmed version, to be used with younger people, should be developed. Cheers!

Tremeur DENIGOT
Tremeur DENIGOT

Maybe. But it can be used integrated in a proper lesson with time asking pupils (16/18 years old) to make their own research on their consumption pattern and understand that it is, anyway, complex.

François Jourde
François Jourde

For young pupils - but also for adults - shouldn't we use more infographics? Especially by making comparisons between orders of magnitude easier to understand? (I have not yet researched what the research says about this).

What I have in mind are also visual metaphors.

Pierantonios PAPAZOGLOU
Pierantonios PAPAZOGLOU

Great notes and comments.
Besides reflections on our "individual impact" on Climate (and relevant resources to 'measure' it), are there any thoughts on how we individually contribute positively? And (subsequently) on how to 'measure' that as well?

Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS
Vassilis KARAMAOUNAS

Hello everyone!

Here are some more carbon footprint calculators available on the internet that you might find helpful:

In case you are interested in measuring your school's footprint:

Yesterday I followed an extremely interesting webinar organised by our E4C Companion FrĂ©dĂ©rick Heissat  , on lowering the carbon frootprint of schools. During the webinar the "Clicks On calculator" (as developed under the Erasmus+ project of the same name) was presented. With it, schools can measure their carbon footprint, raise awareness on climate change, promote action and facilitate students’ behavior. Really usefull and intresting! Check their site: https://www.clickson.eu/en/   


Please log in or sign up to comment.